Vanity Fea: Crítica crítica, crítica acrítica

Subo a Academia, donde faltaba —aunque no se echaba en falta— este artículo sobre teoría de la crítica, más en concreto sobre la crítica acrítica frente a la crítica crítica, sobre replantamientos de perspectiva, sobre el dominio perspectivíctico de la situación, y la interacción dialéctica en cuestiones críticas y lectoras. En inglés, viene a ser

"Acritical Criticism, Critical Criticism:
Reframing, Topsight, and Critical Dialectics."

Y salió en el Literary Theory & Criticism eJournal. También se publicó una variante del mismo en el libro Con/Texts of Persuasion (Kassel: Reichenberger, 2011). En español hay una versión preliminar en ResearchGate: "Crítica acrítica, crítica crítica". Pero el bueno, y largo, es el inglés.

Abstract:

This paper theorizes critical readings from an interactional / argumentative perspective, providing a semiotic and phenomenological analysis of the scale ranging from consonant, "friendly" criticism, to dissonant, confrontational or "unfriendly" criticism. A number of key critical theories (by theorists such as G. W. F. Hegel, Oscar Wilde, Jacques Lacan, Erving Goffman, Norman Holland, Jacques Derrida, Stanley Fish, Paul Ricoeur, Judith Fetterley, John Muller, Alan Sinfield, and H. Porter Abbott) are examined in the light of this conception of criticism, and situated within the framework of interactional pragmatics, of the dialectics of communication, and of a semiotic theory of truth and of consciousness. This working paper was published as "Acritical Criticism, Critical Criticism: Critical Interaction, Reframing and Topsight", in the volume Con/texts of Persuasion, ed. Beatriz Penas Ibáñez, Micaela Muñoz and Marta Conejero. (Problemata Literaria, 69). Kassel: Reichenberger, 2013.

Keywords: Criticism, Interpretation, Hermeneutics, Dialectics, Interaction, Hegel, Lacan, Goffman, Derrida, Ricoeur, Pragmatics

También aquí, en español:

_____. "Crítica acrítica, crítica crítica." In García Landa, Vanity Fea 18 Aug. 2006.

http://garciala.blogia.com/2006/081801-critica-acritica-critica-critica.php

2006

_____. "Acritical Criticism, Critical Criticism / Crítica acrítica, crítica crítica." Online PDF (in Spanish) at Social Science Research Network 6 Dec. 2007. 2008.*

http://ssrn.com/abstract=1064721

http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1064721

2007

Literary Theory and Criticism eJournal 6 Dec. 2007:

http://www.ssrn.com/link/English-Lit-Theory-Criticism.html

2012

_____. "Crítica acrítica, crítica crítica." Online PDF at Zaguán 4 April 2009

http://zaguan.unizar.es/record/3228

2009

_____. "Crítica acrítica, crítica crítica." ResearchGate 27 Sept. 2012.*

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/33419863

2012

_____. "Crítica acrítica, crítica crítica." Academia 13 Dec. 2015.*

https://www.academia.edu/19637165/

2015

Y en inglés:

_____. "Acritical Criticism, Critical Criticism: Reframing, Topsight, and Critical Dialectics." Online PDF at Social Science Research Network 28 August 2008.

http://ssrn.com/abstract=1259696

http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1259696

2008

Literary Theory & Criticism eJournal 28 Aug. 2008.

http://www.ssrn.com/link/English-Lit-Theory-Criticism.html

2012

_____. "Acritical Criticism, Critical Criticism: Reframing, Topsight, and Critical Dialectics." Academia.edu 23 March 2014.*

https://www.academia.edu/172177/

2014

_____. "Acritical Criticism, Critical Criticism: Critical Interaction, Reframing and Topsight." In Con/Texts of Persuasion. Ed. Beatriz Penas et al. Kassel: Edition Reichenberger, 2011. 233-68.*

http://www.reichenberger.de/Pages/plit69.html

2014

_____. "Acritical Criticism, Critical Criticism: Critical Interaction, Reframing, and Topsight." Online at ResearchGate 26 March 2012.*

http://www.researchgate.net/publication/33419996

2014

_____. "Acritical Criticism, Critical Criticism: Reframing, Topsight and Critical Dialectics." Net Sight de José Angel García Landa 24 Oct. 2024.*

https://personal.unizar.es/garciala/publicaciones/Acriticalcritical.pdf

_____. "Crítica crítica, crítica acrítica." In García Landa, Vanity Fea 23 March 2014.*

https://vanityfea.blogspot.com/2014/03/critica-critica-critica-acritica.html

2024